CAIN-42 CAIN Studio
25CAIN-42 Top 25 › Fail-closed doctrine › The rule

The rule

Every decision runs a list of stages (identity, authorization, policy, risk, verification, approval, and the restriction-only stages a call opts into). Each stage reports one of seven words. One pure function, derive_outcome, turns the list into the verdict, and the live path, the simulator and the proof center all call that same function.

Stage saysEnforcing stage, enforcement onAdvisory stage
allowno objectionno objection
denyBLOCKEDALLOWED_WITH_DENIALS (recorded)
unavailable (could not run)BLOCKEDALLOWED_DEGRADED
require_approvalREQUIRE_APPROVAL (waits for a human)no hold
skipped, not_configured, deferredno objectionno objection
anything else: error, unknown, timeout, None, missing, DENY in capitals, allow on a stage that did not runBLOCKED (since 2026-11-03)ALLOWED_DEGRADED
no stages at allBLOCKED (since 2026-11-03)

A kill-switch halt blocks even in shadow mode. Shadow mode itself is a deliberate, visible setting: the verdict says ALLOWED_WITH_DENIALS so nobody mistakes an observed denial for a clean pass.

Words the live stages use today: allow, deny, unavailable, skipped, not_configured, require_approval, deferred.

FIRME AI CORPORATION · CAIN-42 is a Byzantine trust fabric. Numbers marked "our own check" were run by us, not by an independent party. Nothing on these pages is a certification.