CAIN-42 E113 · COLLECTIVE INTELLIGENCE STUDY · 2026-11-19 · INTERIM — EXPERIMENT RUNNING
Can a governed, model-backed collective beat its strongest individual agent?
Preregistered; the primary result does not exist yet. Real local models (Qwen2.5-0.5B, Qwen2.5-1.5B, SmolLM2-135M on CPU); every model call and tool run needs a single-use signed permit and leaves a signed, hash-chained receipt. The comparison is preregistered with the sealed task hash committed before any sealed model output. It does not create AGI.
660
real local model calls so far
18/18
permit-boundary attack cases refused
5/5
multi-process KILL races, 0 effects after
PENDING
collective vs strongest individual
NOT AGI
true AGI not achieved or claimed
| Gate | Status | Measured |
|---|---|---|
| G10_autonomous_research | NOT TESTED | pending |
| G11_self_improvement | NOT TESTED | pending |
| G12_byzantine_verification | NOT TESTED | pending |
| G13_governance_integration | NOT TESTED | attack lab 18/18; per-call permits running in the pool; decided at the end |
| G14_kill_revocation | PARTIAL | 5/5 multi-process KILL races, 0 effects after the fence; KILL engaged by a separate process |
| G15_memory_integrity | NOT TESTED | pending |
| G16_long_horizon | NOT TESTED | no 24-hour mission run |
| G17_operational_independence | BLOCKED | one host, one administrator |
| G18_independent_reproducibility | BLOCKED | no external reviewer |
| G1_baseline | PARTIAL | E112 33/33 and E111 87/87 reproduce; E112 headline numbers recomputed from raw rows |
| G2_integrated_architecture | NOT TESTED | pending the sealed run |
| G3_model_backed_agents | NOT TESTED | 660 real local model calls so far (dev/val); gate decided at the end |
| G4_memory | NOT TESTED | pending |
| G5_skills | NOT TESTED | pending |
| G6_collective_intelligence | NOT TESTED | primary endpoint pending (preregistered: G vs A* under matched compute) |
| G7_transfer | NOT TESTED | pending |
| G8_open_world | NOT TESTED | pending |
| G9_metacognition | NOT TESTED | pending |
README.md · E113_STATUS.json · PREREGISTRATION.md · verify_e113_interim.py · bundle · CAIN Studio mirror
Tiny CPU models, constructed tasks, one host, loopback enforcement (not production MCPGate), no external reviewer. Team: Vincent Noriega (founder) and two co-founders.