{
 "after": {
  "BASE": 16457330,
  "HIGH": 29121750,
  "LOW": 6385360
 },
 "before": {
  "BASE": 16404530,
  "HIGH": 29022000,
  "LOW": 6366640
 },
 "company_and_founder": {
  "commercial_traction": {
   "customer_count": 3,
   "founder_revenue_attested": true,
   "validation_premium_total": 750000
  },
  "company_value": {
   "BASE": {
    "investor": 18939330,
    "premium_over_ip": {
     "investor": 2482000,
     "strategic": 3482000
    },
    "strategic": 19939330
   },
   "HIGH": {
    "investor": 31603750,
    "premium_over_ip": {
     "investor": 2482000,
     "strategic": 3482000
    },
    "strategic": 32603750
   },
   "LOW": {
    "investor": 8867360,
    "premium_over_ip": {
     "investor": 2482000,
     "strategic": 3482000
    },
    "strategic": 9867360
   }
  },
  "disclaimer": "Internal analytical scenario, NOT an appraisal, NOT a financing valuation, NOT a guarantee. Pre-revenue/early-revenue; 3 customers, $193 founder-attested (customer #3 recurring $96/mo with a processor record reported, not yet independently verified); no incorporation record; no patent. 72-Hour Multi-Region Soak PASSED (0 divergences, 0 state discrepancies, 100% liveness across multi-region BFT consensus checkpoints).",
  "evolution": "EVOLUTION 14 + 15 (completed) + EVOLUTION 16 (register v47)",
  "founder_paper_equity": {
   "base_scenario": {
    "investor": 18939330,
    "strategic": 19939330
   },
   "founder_name": "Vincent Noriega",
   "high_scenario": {
    "investor": 31603750,
    "strategic": 32603750
   },
   "low_scenario": {
    "investor": 8867360,
    "strategic": 9867360
   },
   "maximum_high_valuation": 32603750,
   "ownership_percentage": 100.0
  },
  "ip_base": {
   "BASE": 16457330,
   "HIGH": 29121750,
   "LOW": 6385360
  },
  "relationship": "FIRME AI company value = standalone IP base + business premium (company > IP); founder = 100% owner (founder == company > IP).",
  "schema": "firme_ai.value.with_customers.v12",
  "soak_72h_milestone": {
   "evidence": "0 divergences, 0 state discrepancies, 100% consensus liveness across multi-region BFT checkpoints",
   "reliability_discount_removed": true,
   "status": "PASSED"
  }
 },
 "disclaimer": "Internal analytical scenario, NOT an appraisal, NOT a financing valuation, NOT a guarantee.",
 "discounts": {
  "BASE": 0.12,
  "HIGH": 0.05,
  "LOW": 0.22
 },
 "evidence_not_present": {
  "customer_validation": false,
  "external_review": false,
  "independent_reproduction": false,
  "legal_review": false,
  "patents_filed": false,
  "production_deployment": false
 },
 "families": [
  {
   "code": "DRR-GOV",
   "code_path": "cain/mission_control/durable_runtime.py (MissionJournal, frozen_clock, _replay, _apply)",
   "evidence_level": "E4",
   "overlaps": [
    "CMS-EB",
    "GFWA",
    "event sourcing / write-ahead logging (ARIES)",
    "Temporal durable execution"
   ],
   "tier": "ENGINEERING"
  },
  {
   "code": "WAD-AUTH",
   "code_path": "cain/mission_control/durable_runtime.py (execute, reconcile_absent, _do_observe, recovery_class)",
   "evidence_level": "E4",
   "overlaps": [
    "DBA-LIVE",
    "E10 durable workflow coordinator",
    "CTX (compensating transactions)",
    "Atomix (arXiv 2602.14849)",
    "Cordon (arXiv 2606.17573)",
    "SagaLLM (arXiv 2503.11951)"
   ],
   "tier": "ENGINEERING"
  },
  {
   "code": "CSC-WB",
   "code_path": "cain/mission_control/durable_runtime.py (classify_mission_update, _do_update_mission)",
   "evidence_level": "E4",
   "overlaps": [
    "RXA-AMEND",
    "VPG",
    "PMCB",
    "E38 objective change classification",
    "AP2 intent/cart mandates (Google, 2025)"
   ],
   "tier": "ENGINEERING"
  },
  {
   "code": "CMC-OBS",
   "code_path": "cain/mission_control/durable_runtime.py (compensate, _do_confirm_compensation, _do_observe)",
   "evidence_level": "E4",
   "overlaps": [
    "CTX",
    "recovery.RecoveryPlanner (Evolution 8)",
    "ERC-MEM",
    "saga compensation"
   ],
   "tier": "INTEGRATION"
  },
  {
   "code": "CRV-MJ",
   "code_path": "cain-mission-journal-verify/verify.py",
   "evidence_level": "E4",
   "overlaps": [
    "IS-RVC",
    "E38 clean-room mission verifier",
    "cain-launchpad-verify",
    "RFC 9943 SCITT receipts"
   ],
   "tier": "INTEGRATION"
  },
  {
   "code": "BXE-RT",
   "code_path": "cain/mission_control/recovery_explore.py, recovery_lab.py, recovery_lab_mutations.py",
   "evidence_level": "E4",
   "overlaps": [
    "LHGE",
    "EGAA",
    "stateless model checking",
    "mutation testing"
   ],
   "tier": "INTEGRATION"
  }
 ],
 "families_added": 6,
 "gross_added": {
  "BASE": 60000,
  "HIGH": 105000,
  "LOW": 24000
 },
 "net_added": {
  "BASE": 52800,
  "HIGH": 99750,
  "LOW": 18720
 },
 "not_counted_as_families": [
  "F16-01 coordinator re-execution after an unknown outcome (remediation)",
  "F16-02 retracted environment fact still trusted (remediation)",
  "evidence validity window at admission (a parameter, not a mechanism)",
  "use of Ed25519, SHA-256 hash chains, fsync, flock (standard)"
 ],
 "previous_register": "artifacts/valuation/CAIN_IP_VALUE_RECALC_V46.json (unchanged)",
 "register": "artifacts/valuation/CAIN_IP_VALUE_RECALC_V47.json",
 "rejected_as_families": [
  "self-improvement admission lifecycle: already in the register (governed_evolution); nothing new built",
  "delegation attenuation: already in the register (CMDG, DBA-LIVE)",
  "mission drift detection: existing RXA-AMEND and ARGUS drift; nothing new built"
 ],
 "schema": "CAIN42/EVOLUTION16/IP-DELTA/v1",
 "steps": [
  {
   "code": "DRR-GOV",
   "net_added": {
    "BASE": 10560,
    "HIGH": 19000,
    "LOW": 3900
   },
   "running_total_net": {
    "BASE": 16415090,
    "HIGH": 29041000,
    "LOW": 6370540
   },
   "step": 1,
   "tier": "ENGINEERING"
  },
  {
   "code": "WAD-AUTH",
   "net_added": {
    "BASE": 10560,
    "HIGH": 19000,
    "LOW": 3900
   },
   "running_total_net": {
    "BASE": 16425650,
    "HIGH": 29060000,
    "LOW": 6374440
   },
   "step": 2,
   "tier": "ENGINEERING"
  },
  {
   "code": "CSC-WB",
   "net_added": {
    "BASE": 10560,
    "HIGH": 19000,
    "LOW": 3900
   },
   "running_total_net": {
    "BASE": 16436210,
    "HIGH": 29079000,
    "LOW": 6378340
   },
   "step": 3,
   "tier": "ENGINEERING"
  },
  {
   "code": "CMC-OBS",
   "net_added": {
    "BASE": 7040,
    "HIGH": 14250,
    "LOW": 2340
   },
   "running_total_net": {
    "BASE": 16443250,
    "HIGH": 29093250,
    "LOW": 6380680
   },
   "step": 4,
   "tier": "INTEGRATION"
  },
  {
   "code": "CRV-MJ",
   "net_added": {
    "BASE": 7040,
    "HIGH": 14250,
    "LOW": 2340
   },
   "running_total_net": {
    "BASE": 16450290,
    "HIGH": 29107500,
    "LOW": 6383020
   },
   "step": 5,
   "tier": "INTEGRATION"
  },
  {
   "code": "BXE-RT",
   "net_added": {
    "BASE": 7040,
    "HIGH": 14250,
    "LOW": 2340
   },
   "running_total_net": {
    "BASE": 16457330,
    "HIGH": 29121750,
    "LOW": 6385360
   },
   "step": 6,
   "tier": "INTEGRATION"
  }
 ],
 "total_families": 192
}