{
 "agency_graph": {
  "edges": [
   "HIRES",
   "DELEGATES",
   "CONTRACTS",
   "EXECUTES",
   "PROVES",
   "VERIFIES",
   "PAYS",
   "DEPENDS_ON",
   "SUBCONTRACTS",
   "REVOKES",
   "RECOVERS",
   "REVIEWS"
  ],
  "nodes": [
   "agent",
   "service",
   "organization",
   "capability",
   "contract",
   "transaction",
   "proof",
   "identity",
   "authority",
   "tool",
   "model",
   "runtime",
   "resource",
   "incident",
   "payment",
   "dispute"
  ]
 },
 "authority": "NONE",
 "cloud": {
  "governance_cloud": "NOT DEPLOYED",
  "marketplace": "NOT DEPLOYED (local registry only)"
 },
 "contract_sections": [
  "parties",
  "identities",
  "capabilities",
  "objectives",
  "obligations",
  "prohibitions",
  "permissions",
  "resource_limits",
  "time_limits",
  "budget",
  "evidence_requirements",
  "proof_requirements",
  "security_requirements",
  "escalation",
  "revocation",
  "dispute",
  "recovery",
  "termination"
 ],
 "dispute_states": [
  "OPEN",
  "UNDER_REVIEW",
  "EVIDENCE_REQUIRED",
  "MEDIATION",
  "RESOLVED",
  "ESCALATED",
  "UNKNOWN"
 ],
 "escrow_states": [
  "FUNDS_COMMITTED",
  "CONDITIONS",
  "EXECUTION",
  "PROOF",
  "VERIFICATION",
  "SETTLEMENT",
  "DISPUTE"
 ],
 "lifecycle": [
  "DISCOVER",
  "IDENTIFY",
  "VERIFY",
  "EVALUATE",
  "NEGOTIATE",
  "CONTRACT",
  "AUTHORIZE",
  "EXECUTE",
  "PROVE",
  "SETTLE",
  "RATE",
  "REASSESS",
  "RENEW_OR_REVOKE"
 ],
 "match_classes": [
  "MATCH",
  "PARTIAL_MATCH",
  "UNKNOWN",
  "NON_COMPLIANT"
 ],
 "moat_graph": {
  "moats": {
   "agent_labor_marketplace": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "economic_digital_twin": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "economic_threat_intelligence": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "governance_aware_auctions": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "governance_aware_discovery": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "governance_aware_procurement": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "governance_aware_routing": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "governance_contracts": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "governance_reputation": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "governance_risk_analytics": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "governance_warranty_architecture": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "machine_agency_directory": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "machine_bidding": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "machine_contracts": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "machine_dispute_infrastructure": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "machine_economy_knowledge_graph": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "machine_economy_telemetry": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "machine_organization_marketplace": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "machine_procurement": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "machine_reputation": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "machine_service_conformance": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "machine_service_digital_twins": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "machine_service_passports": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "machine_service_quality_graph": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "machine_subcontracting": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "procurement_simulation": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "proof_backed_marketplace": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "service_chain_proof": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "service_substitution_governance": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   },
   "service_supply_chain_graph": {
    "copyability": "formats and code patterns",
    "data_advantage": "machine economy events (none collected yet)",
    "dependency": "external adoption and real traffic",
    "developer_value": "TESTED library only",
    "enterprise_value": "UNPROVEN",
    "evidence": "technical prototype only",
    "interoperability": "CAIN-MSDP is experimental; no external adoption",
    "market_moat": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "network_effect": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "switching_cost": "NOT ESTABLISHED",
    "technical_difficulty": "requires the whole governed path plus a machine economy to hold"
   }
  },
  "note": "technical foundations only; nothing here is a proven moat"
 },
 "moat_placement": {
  "extends": [
   "the seven moats with a machine agency exchange layer"
  ],
  "new_moat": false
 },
 "msdp": {
  "protocol": "CAIN-MSDP",
  "standard": false
 },
 "products": {
  "CAIN Agent Labor": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)",
  "CAIN Agent Procurement": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)",
  "CAIN Agent Store": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)",
  "CAIN Dispute": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)",
  "CAIN Economy Simulator": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)",
  "CAIN Governance Warranty": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)",
  "CAIN Machine Contracts": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)",
  "CAIN Machine Economy": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)",
  "CAIN Machine Organizations": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)",
  "CAIN Machine Reputation": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)",
  "CAIN Marketplace": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)",
  "CAIN Procurement Intelligence": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)",
  "CAIN Proof Market": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)",
  "CAIN Service Exchange": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)",
  "CAIN Service Intelligence": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)",
  "CAIN Threat Intelligence": "ARCHITECTURE / TESTED library (not deployed)"
 },
 "schema": "cain42.e36.registers.v1",
 "settlement": {
  "bank": false,
  "custodial": false,
  "insurance": false,
  "underwriting": false,
  "units": "SYNTHETIC TEST UNITS"
 }
}