CAIN-42 Evolution 31 — Proof of Governance

TESTED library · not hosted · not third-party reviewed · ephemeral keys.

A governance proof says exactly which checks passed for one specific action: who acted, under which delegation and policy, that E8 committed it, that it executed, and (only once an observer saw it) that the expected result happened. It is evidence, never permission.

Invariants 252/252; scenarios 1269/1269 held; mutation 12/12 killed; conformance G8 (CAIN internal profile); TypeScript SDK INTACT (tamper BROKEN); tests 15 passed / 0 failed; clean-room verifier INTACT (1676/1676).

End-to-end governed action

StepResult
HUMAN_ORGANIZATIONOK
MACHINE_INSTITUTIONOK
TRUST_DOMAINOK
AGENT_MODEL_RUNTIMEOK
IDENTITYOK
CAPABILITYOK
DELEGATIONOK
AUTHORITYOK
POLICYOK
TRUSTOK
RISKOK
WORLD_CONTEXTOK
DECISIONOK
AUTHORIZATIONOK
E8_ACTION_COMMITOK
EXECUTION_BOUNDARYOK
REAL_WORLD_EFFECTOK
POSTCONDITIONOK
EVIDENCEOK
GOVERNANCE_PROOFOK
TRANSPARENCY_LOGOK
INDEPENDENT_WITNESSOK
CLEAN_ROOM_VERIFIEROK
CONFORMANCEOK
PUBLIC_VERIFICATIONOK
CAIN_LEARNSOK
NEXT_GOVERNANCE_DECISIONOK

Adversarial and conformance categories

CategoryHeld
proof_mutation136/136
evidence_integrity200/200
verifier_disagreement100/100
replay_revocation117/117
cross_domain122/122
enforcement_binding104/104
protocol_conformance107/107
authority_laws107/107
policy_portability104/104
proof_lifecycle132/132
adversarial_misc40/40

Governance coverage (not universal)

DimensionClassBasis
identityENFORCEDunregistered client refused
actionENFORCEDunmapped operation refused
protocolPARTIALLY_ENFORCED13 in-process carriers through E25; agent/model runtimes and workflow engines have no carrier
capabilityENFORCEDcapability above level refused
executionENFORCEDsealed executor refuses outside the E8 commit boundary
dataUNCONTROLLEDno data-flow / DLP control in E31
memoryPARTIALLY_ENFORCEDonly memories passed through the E30 kernel are checked
delegationENFORCEDwider subagent refused
subagentPARTIALLY_ENFORCEDonly E28-spawned subagents are bounded
physical_actionUNCONTROLLEDrobot environment is UNENFORCED: refused, not governed
economic_actionPARTIALLY_ENFORCEDE29 treasury is sealed; synthetic units only, no payment rail
cloud_resourcePARTIALLY_ENFORCEDcloud_api is an in-process adapter; no real cloud account
computer_usePARTIALLY_ENFORCEDcomputer_use is an in-process adapter; no real desktop
recoveryUNKNOWNnot probed in E31
evidenceENFORCEDUAR, E8 and proof-log chains verify