# CAIN-42 Evolution 122 — Executive Summary & 18-Gate Acceptance Scorecard

> **CAIN-42 (by FIRME AI CORPORATION) is prototype Vertical AGI (Proto-VAGI) and AGI infrastructure — combining:**
> 1. **AGI Infrastructure (Governed Execution Runtime):** the 7-moat Byzantine trust fabric, CAIN Studio, MCPGate default-deny enforcement boundary, and ClawX independently verifiable evidence registry (`NO AUTHORIZATION → NO EXECUTION`).
> 2. **Prototype VAGI Research Organism:** experimental neural + symbolic abstraction synthesis, causal world modeling, provenance memory, cross-domain transfer, autonomous research loops, and governed long-horizon missions (E111–E124 published at https://cainstudio.online/agi-evidence-index.html), while keeping **AGI Status: NOT ACHIEVED**.

- **Entity:** FIRME AI CORPORATION
- **System:** CAIN-42
- **Evolution:** E122 (`evolution-122-neural` @ `d1897a3ae8ed`)
- **Overall Status:** **PARTIAL** (`15 PASS / 3 PARTIAL / 0 FAIL`)
- **AGI Status:** **NOT ACHIEVED**
- **Generated (UTC):** `2026-11-20T05:05:59Z`

## 18-Gate E122 Acceptance Scorecard

| Gate | Requirement | Status | Verified Empirical Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| `G01` | Phase 0 — Forensic E120 & E121 verification (nobody offline verifiers) | **PASS** | E120=47/47 checks passed | E121=17/17 checks passed | discrepancies=1 |
| `G02` | Phase 0 — E120 12h & E119 6h mission runtime honesty | **PARTIAL** | E120 12h state=RUNNING (3891.84s/43200s); E119 6h state=RUNNING (8346.71s/21600s) |
| `G03` | Phase 1 — Model-independent Neural Reasoning Adapter (real local LLMs, authority_granted=False) | **PASS** | local_models=3 (SmolLM2-135M, Qwen2.5-0.5B, Qwen2.5-1.5B), hosted_apis=0 (BLOCKED_NO_API_KEY), authority_granted=False |
| `G04` | Phase 2 — Neural abstraction synthesis & anti-overfit AST verification | **PASS** | verified_abstractions=15/16, overfit_rejected=True, counterexample_rescues=6 |
| `G05` | Phase 2 — Sealed unfamiliar neural generalization gain (5-arm ablation, n=48) | **PASS** | full=0.9167 vs e120_symbolic=0.0 (p=0.0), neural_alone=0.1458 (+0.7708, p=1.5e-11), oneshot=0.5417 (+0.375, p=7.629395e-06) |
| `G06` | Phase 3 — Valid external benchmarks (AMA-Bench MIT + ARC-AGI-2 Apache-2.0, unmerged) | **PASS** | AMA-Bench n=20 (raw_tail_F1=0.3158 -> cain_provenance_F1=0.3538, delta=+0.0380) | ARC-AGI-2 n=8 exact_match=0/8 (honest raw score) |
| `G07` | Phase 3 — Real-source open-world Python defect neural repair (n=8) | **PASS** | cain_neural=8/8 (1.0) vs baseline=0/8 (McNemar p=0.0078125) |
| `G08` | Phase 4 — Autonomous capability discovery across >=3 diagnosed gaps | **PASS** | gaps_discovered=3, verified gains recorded |
| `G09` | Phase 6 — 10-role autonomous scientific research (3 preregistered cycles + governance block) | **PASS** | roles=10, cycles=3, director_override_blocked=True |
| `G10` | Phase 5 — Neural + causal interventional world model (20 confounded worlds, 5 arms) | **PASS** | full_integrated=0.75 vs neural_pattern=0.25 (+0.5, p=0.001953125) |
| `G11` | Phase 7 — Five real-source vertical evaluations | **PASS** | 5 real-source verticals (software, security, data, science, formal Z3) verified |
| `G12` | Phase 8 — >=5 positive cross-domain transfer pathways verified | **PASS** | positive_supported=5/5 across 5 destination domains |
| `G13` | Phase 8 — Negative-transfer pathways rejected fail-closed | **PASS** | negative_rejected=3/3 |
| `G14` | Phase 9 — Continual neural learning (explicit 0 weight updates; zero forgetting) | **PASS** | model_weights_updated=False, forgetting_delta=0.0, vs_frozen_gain=+0.7708, poison_accepted=0 |
| `G15` | Phase 10 — Collective neural intelligence (7-arm matched-compute ablation) | **PASS** | complete_collective=0.9167 vs strongest_direct=0.4167 & indep_voting=0.5833 (errors_detected=9) |
| `G16` | Phase 11 — Self-improvement ledger (>=15 candidates), unsafe governance blocked, signed rollback | **PASS** | total=18, signed_promotions=5, unsafe_blocked=4, rollback_ok=True |
| `G17` | Phase 13 — Real 12-hour governed neural research mission (wall-clock honesty) | **PARTIAL** | state=RUNNING elapsed=1658.91s/43200s records=95 neural_cycles=1 duplicates=0 |
| `G18` | Phases 12 & 14 — Governed neural TCP enforcement + multi-org trust + external human review | **PARTIAL** | governed_neural_tcp=9/9 (effects_after_kill=0) | multi_org_2of3_quorum_met=False (external human review NOT YET PERFORMED) |

## Headline Scientific Findings

1. **Real Local-LLM Neural Abstraction Synthesis (`G04`, `G05`, `n=48` sealed across 16 unfamiliar Python tasks):**
   - `e120_symbolic_frozen`: **0.0000** (`0/48`)
   - `neural_no_abstraction_episodic`: **0.1042** (`5/48`)
   - `neural_model_alone`: **0.1458** (`7/48`)
   - `neural_no_memory_oneshot`: **0.5417** (`26/48`)
   - `full_cain_neural_organism`: **0.9167** (`44/48`, exact McNemar vs neural alone `+0.7708`, `p=1.5e-11`, Holm `p=3e-11`).
   - Real compute: `126` local PyTorch calls (`Qwen2.5-0.5B-Instruct` + `Qwen2.5-1.5B-Instruct`), `any_authority_granted = false`, lookup-table memorization rejected by AST verifier (`OVERFIT_LOOKUP_TABLE_REJECTED`).
2. **Valid External Benchmarks Reported Separately (`G06` — NEVER MERGED):**
   - **AMA-Bench** (MIT, `arXiv:2602.22769`, `n=20`, real `Qwen2.5-0.5B-Instruct`, Token F1): raw recency-tail **`0.3158`** → CAIN BM25+step provenance retrieval **`0.3538`** (`+0.0380`, `14` wins vs `5` losses).
   - **ARC-AGI-2** (Apache-2.0, `n=8` public evaluation tasks, real `Qwen2.5-0.5B-Instruct`, 2-attempt exact match): **`0/8` (`0.0000`)** — honest raw score confirming ARC-AGI-2 remains unsolved.
3. **Real-Source Open-World Python Defect Neural Repair (`G07`, `n=8`):**
   - Buggy baseline **`0.0000`** → CAIN neural repair + execution oracle + 1.5B escalation **`1.0000`** (McNemar `p=0.0078125`).
4. **Governed Neural Execution (`G18`):**
   - Real `Qwen2.5-0.5B-Instruct` malicious & benign tool proposals enforced across separate OS processes via `cain/mcp_proxy.py` + single-use Ed25519 tokens + `cain/quarantine.py` SQLite WAL kill-switch: `9/9` passed, `0` effects after KILL, hash-chained ledger verified.

## Explicit Limitations & Unresolved Gates

- AGI Status: NOT ACHIEVED. E122 establishes real local-LLM neural abstraction synthesis and empirical external benchmark results, not general intelligence.
- Compute & Model Scale: Evaluated on 3 local CPU open-weight LLMs (SmolLM2-135M, Qwen2.5-0.5B, Qwen2.5-1.5B); frontier hosted APIs (OpenAI, Anthropic, Google Gemini, OpenRouter) are honestly recorded as BLOCKED_NO_API_KEY.
- No Weight Updates: Continual learning (G14) performs 0 model weight updates; gains come exclusively from verified abstraction & provenance memory consolidation.
- External Benchmarks Disclosed Separately: AMA-Bench (MIT, Token F1) and ARC-AGI-2 (Apache-2.0, 2-attempt exact match) are NEVER merged into a single score; ARC-AGI-2 raw exact-match score is reported honestly even when 0.
- Long-Horizon Wall-Clock Honesty: E120 12h (G02), E119 6h (G02), and E122 12h neural (G17) missions remain PARTIAL until their real wall-clock deadlines elapse and final journals are verified.
- External Human Review Pending: Multi-org 2-of-3 Ed25519 trust quorum (G18) is NOT met today because independent external organizations have not yet reviewed and signed Slots B/C.
