# E111 Negative Results (preserved)

- **S2_science_causal was not promoted.** Held-out 40/40 vs baseline 36/40; the exact McNemar test gives
  p = 0.125. A correct-looking
  procedure that does not separate statistically is retained as NOT_PROMOTED.
- **Transfer pathway T2 misses 5/30** positive tasks. It is still statistically supported, but it is not perfect.
- **Blind transfer failed**, as designed: A and B have identical scores on four pathways because applying a source
  rule without its precondition does not help.
- **Self-improvement promotion is withheld.** The sealed winner is real, but no owner approval exists, so it is not
  enabled. The E110 negative result is preserved and not rewritten.
- **No administrative independence.** The second host is owner-administered; G6 is PARTIAL, not PASS.
- **No external reviewer.** G7 is BLOCKED. The prepared packet is not a review.
- **The collective specialists are deterministic code**, so the quality gain demonstrates independent recomputation,
  not language-model collaboration.
- **The six-hour interruption test is a separate short run**, because the live mission was already running.
