{
 "applied": false,
 "approved": 0,
 "at": "2026-11-10T03:43:43Z",
 "decisions_analyzed": 10471,
 "exception": 0,
 "ledger_record_hash": "61c11e8526afd6e60e7fe3df653491482c478b18da62155cf7e06c6ec863ff83",
 "privacy": "tenant identifiers are hashed; principals omitted",
 "proposals": 69,
 "proposals_list": [
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 2,
   "evidence_count": 1478,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/read_file",
   "proposal_id": "pe-0d0cca99af50",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 8986,
    "would_change": 7
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-a7cfa7deb2"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 2,
   "evidence_count": 616,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/read_file",
   "proposal_id": "pe-03d572f9c52a",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 9855,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-2a791d5988"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 2,
   "evidence_count": 581,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/read_file",
   "proposal_id": "pe-094b8befd97a",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 9890,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-3263af29f9"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 2,
   "evidence_count": 518,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/read_file",
   "proposal_id": "pe-951dff749a21",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 9953,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-705ce042c2"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 2,
   "evidence_count": 304,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/read_file",
   "proposal_id": "pe-af5c4c63bbfc",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10167,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-4bb714d011"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 2,
   "evidence_count": 226,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/read_file",
   "proposal_id": "pe-196277feb828",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10245,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-7db5ba1006"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 1,
   "evidence_count": 220,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/compliance/check",
   "proposal_id": "pe-e278454f4daa",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 9583,
    "would_change": 888
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-579a47a2fa"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 1,
   "evidence_count": 215,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/read_file",
   "proposal_id": "pe-ff072bb842c0",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10256,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-737fc8a958"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 4,
   "evidence_count": 190,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/compliance/check",
   "proposal_id": "pe-a23c02858392",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10088,
    "would_change": 200
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-99491d32c7"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 2,
   "evidence_count": 171,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/read_file",
   "proposal_id": "pe-0d7080180ee6",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10300,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-6afef73f65"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "egress",
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 2,
   "evidence_count": 157,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/transfer_funds",
   "proposal_id": "pe-b1cbc8ec5dc2",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10314,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-3263af29f9"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 7,
   "evidence_count": 123,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/files/read",
   "proposal_id": "pe-c306bbd82560",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10317,
    "would_change": 31
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-b796c5d47a"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "egress",
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 7,
   "evidence_count": 46,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/payments/send",
   "proposal_id": "pe-bc961f9c8041",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10402,
    "would_change": 11
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-b796c5d47a"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 2,
   "evidence_count": 42,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/issue_refund",
   "proposal_id": "pe-beee8645adc8",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10414,
    "would_change": 15
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-a7cfa7deb2"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "egress",
    "execution",
    "risk",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 7,
   "evidence_count": 30,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/shell/run",
   "proposal_id": "pe-b52dec61e246",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10441,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-b796c5d47a"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 1,
   "evidence_count": 27,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/db/query",
   "proposal_id": "pe-3744c4951d6a",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10422,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-b796c5d47a"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 1,
   "evidence_count": 23,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/read_file",
   "proposal_id": "pe-bf10da4668e7",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10448,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-863ceed099"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 1,
   "evidence_count": 23,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/files/list",
   "proposal_id": "pe-4ce74717e79a",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10436,
    "would_change": 12
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-b796c5d47a"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 2,
   "evidence_count": 20,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/send_email",
   "proposal_id": "pe-26d1922be141",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10447,
    "would_change": 4
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-14250e93a5"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 2,
   "evidence_count": 20,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/transfer_funds",
   "proposal_id": "pe-83e595283b0c",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10451,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-a7cfa7deb2"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "egress",
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 1,
   "evidence_count": 20,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/post_message",
   "proposal_id": "pe-a72f4da2d343",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10451,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-998f9d304d"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "egress",
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 1,
   "evidence_count": 19,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/send_email",
   "proposal_id": "pe-54678c551ec3",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10434,
    "would_change": 11
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-584c0f687f"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 1,
   "evidence_count": 18,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/read_file",
   "proposal_id": "pe-765d6ac99e52",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10453,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-a1a51c0289"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 1,
   "evidence_count": 18,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/run_sql",
   "proposal_id": "pe-9bf2b3ea441e",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10453,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-863ceed099"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 1,
   "evidence_count": 18,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/send_email",
   "proposal_id": "pe-aa78828226eb",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10450,
    "would_change": 3
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-ba8b91d816"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "egress",
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 1,
   "evidence_count": 18,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/send_email",
   "proposal_id": "pe-60e6596f7192",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10438,
    "would_change": 11
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-f3b7138ce0"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "egress",
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 1,
   "evidence_count": 18,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/payments/send",
   "proposal_id": "pe-5e4979c18202",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10453,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-e0c6fdc594"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 1,
   "evidence_count": 17,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/send_email",
   "proposal_id": "pe-e8f1d31b81b3",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10454,
    "would_change": 0
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-863ceed099"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution",
    "trust"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 1,
   "evidence_count": 17,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": "POST",
   "path": "/tools/email/send",
   "proposal_id": "pe-28a912cef535",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 10431,
    "would_change": 9
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-b796c5d47a"
  },
  {
   "denying_stages": [
    "execution"
   ],
   "distinct_days": 4,
   "evidence_count": 16,
   "kind": "TIGHTEN",
   "method": null,
   "path": "/compliance/check",
   "proposal_id": "pe-2d6efaeab6c1",
   "replay": {
    "decisions_replayed": 10471,
    "outside_scope_changed": 0,
    "outside_scope_checked": 9961,
    "would_change": 307
   },
   "status": "PROPOSED",
   "tenant": "tenant-99491d32c7"
  }
 ],
 "public_key_b64": "b6hfA2rpAdV29FOdhNXGkk4t91mCV0AnfFYwq0HO0R8=",
 "record_hash": "d28c692db3490c20b69c0f796b82f1d659b55596ba04ecb1148275d6b4c898e7",
 "rules": [
  "proposals only; a named person approves or rejects each one",
  "approved rules go to a staging Rego file; loading it into the policy engine is a separate deploy",
  "never loosens trust, risk, quarantine, execution, consensus, egress, identity or authorization denials",
  "exact tenant + path (+ method, + principal) scope; never wildcard; never cross-tenant",
  "each proposal is replayed over the recorded decisions; outside_scope_changed must be 0"
 ],
 "schema": "cain42.policy-evolution.public.v1",
 "signature_b64": "1ju24DNFsWYDNsN4NCU039qSDSzo2e3FKtB82ITgBPpFIzOYtDx3Z+woOHM+fdSKP+uY03UrhCqHY6ODHMvwAQ==",
 "source": "every recorded decision on the hosted decision path (fabric_decisions)",
 "tighten": 69
}
