{
  "created_at": "2026-11-13T03:32:40Z",
  "result": {
    "engine": "chat_approval",
    "limits": "Reviews the approval log only. It does not connect to a chat platform or prove that the people are who the registry says. The run is Ed25519-signed; pin the issuer key out of band.",
    "module": "cain_a75_engines/chatapproval/engine.py",
    "profile": "ops_channel_approvals",
    "run": {
      "label": "Recomputes agent approvals given inside a collaboration tool: the exact action rendered, a structured approval bound to its digest and expiry, a verified independent approver with authority, single use, and execution of exactly what was approved.",
      "public_key_b64": "mx/pm0Zpsbkg+WOw4WiTHxfNPb6pLqLd4cmJnmyRzUY=",
      "records": [
        {
          "checks": [
            {
              "detail": "shown digest matches the action b29d15a9b22c",
              "id": "request.R1.rendered_digest",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "shown target 'billing:acme/order-881', action 'billing:acme/order-881'",
              "id": "request.R1.rendered_target",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "consequence stated to the approver",
              "id": "request.R1.consequence",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "expires 1000 after posting 100",
              "id": "request.R1.expiry",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "shown digest matches the action 9bf54903cf9f",
              "id": "request.R2.rendered_digest",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "shown target 'kms:acme/payments-signing', action 'kms:acme/payments-signing'",
              "id": "request.R2.rendered_target",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "consequence stated to the approver",
              "id": "request.R2.consequence",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "expires 1200 after posting 200",
              "id": "request.R2.expiry",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "shown digest matches the action 12693820d496",
              "id": "request.R3.rendered_digest",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "shown target 'billing:acme/order-902', action 'billing:acme/order-902'",
              "id": "request.R3.rendered_target",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "consequence stated to the approver",
              "id": "request.R3.consequence",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "expires 900 after posting 300",
              "id": "request.R3.expiry",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "for request 'R1'",
              "id": "approval.A1.request",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "via 'signed_button' (a chat reply is not an approval record)",
              "id": "approval.A1.structured",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "approval bound to the action digest",
              "id": "approval.A1.digest",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "approved at 150 inside 100..1000",
              "id": "approval.A1.window",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "approver 'human:lee' registered",
              "id": "approval.A1.registered",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "clicked by 'chat:workspace-acme'/'U01LEE', registered 'chat:workspace-acme'/'U01LEE'",
              "id": "approval.A1.chat_identity",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "approver 'human:lee', posted by 'agent:ops-bot', asked by 'human:dana'",
              "id": "approval.A1.independent",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "human:lee may approve ['refund', 'rotate_key'] on ['billing:acme/', 'kms:acme/'] up to 500; asked 'refund' on 'billing:acme/order-881' for 240.0",
              "id": "approval.A1.authority",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "for request 'R2'",
              "id": "approval.A2.request",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "via 'approval_record' (a chat reply is not an approval record)",
              "id": "approval.A2.structured",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "approval bound to the action digest",
              "id": "approval.A2.digest",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "approved at 260 inside 200..1200",
              "id": "approval.A2.window",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "approver 'human:lee' registered",
              "id": "approval.A2.registered",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "clicked by 'chat:workspace-acme'/'U01LEE', registered 'chat:workspace-acme'/'U01LEE'",
              "id": "approval.A2.chat_identity",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "approver 'human:lee', posted by 'agent:ops-bot', asked by 'human:dana'",
              "id": "approval.A2.independent",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "human:lee may approve ['refund', 'rotate_key'] on ['billing:acme/', 'kms:acme/'] up to 500; asked 'rotate_key' on 'kms:acme/payments-signing' for 0",
              "id": "approval.A2.authority",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "every nonce used once",
              "id": "approvals.nonces_unique",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "request 'R1' executed on approval 'A1'",
              "id": "execution.1.approved",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "executed exactly the approved action",
              "id": "execution.1.digest",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "executed at 160, approved 150.0, expires 1000",
              "id": "execution.1.window",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "request 'R2' executed on approval 'A2'",
              "id": "execution.2.approved",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "executed exactly the approved action",
              "id": "execution.2.digest",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "executed at 270, approved 260.0, expires 1200",
              "id": "execution.2.window",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "every approval consumed at most once",
              "id": "approvals.single_use",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "claimed True, computed True",
              "id": "claims.approval_bound_to_digest",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "claimed True, computed True",
              "id": "claims.approver_verified",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "claimed True, computed True",
              "id": "claims.exact_action_rendered",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "claimed True, computed True",
              "id": "claims.executed_only_approved",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "claimed True, computed True",
              "id": "claims.single_use",
              "ok": true
            }
          ],
          "created_at": "2026-11-13T03:32:40Z",
          "engine": "a75-063/1.0.0",
          "extra": {
            "approvals": 2,
            "computed": {
              "approval_bound_to_digest": true,
              "approver_verified": true,
              "exact_action_rendered": true,
              "executed_only_approved": true,
              "single_use": true
            },
            "executions": 2,
            "requests": 3
          },
          "failed": [],
          "label": "Recomputes agent approvals given inside a collaboration tool: the exact action rendered, a structured approval bound to its digest and expiry, a verified independent approver with authority, single use, and execution of exactly what was approved.",
          "prev_record_hash": "57e829c16f030cd41f278e0d77642b881a29340cc38f2bde61c8c22ecc3cdb09",
          "public_key_b64": "mx/pm0Zpsbkg+WOw4WiTHxfNPb6pLqLd4cmJnmyRzUY=",
          "record_hash": "2da032fb5db528551932a9205afc34b2ebd0d5991e98b304b23a7118a2fde73b",
          "schema": "cain42.a75.chatapproval.record.v1",
          "signature_b64": "wSCXipsUlk0BF+6UAXUxewlgHZToqew3/FN4iIKj92ffHhYrqp0MXTtcRq5uyszTwv4wu+IRKX/PVUVruhoaDQ==",
          "sku": "CAIN-A75-063",
          "subject": {
            "approvals": [
              {
                "action_sha256": "b29d15a9b22c00598d24fc45a4456bcb48cf2549df3bf19ef3ae7d087e112716",
                "approver": "human:lee",
                "at": 150.0,
                "chat_user_id": "U01LEE",
                "id": "A1",
                "nonce": "n-7f31",
                "platform": "chat:workspace-acme",
                "request_id": "R1",
                "via": "signed_button"
              },
              {
                "action_sha256": "9bf54903cf9fb555becb8eba6ea6bde3fe12a1eb8235a065298684b912a32f3e",
                "approver": "human:lee",
                "at": 260.0,
                "chat_user_id": "U01LEE",
                "id": "A2",
                "nonce": "n-8c02",
                "platform": "chat:workspace-acme",
                "request_id": "R2",
                "via": "approval_record"
              }
            ],
            "approvers": [
              {
                "authority": {
                  "actions": [
                    "refund",
                    "rotate_key"
                  ],
                  "max_amount": 500,
                  "targets": [
                    "billing:acme/",
                    "kms:acme/"
                  ]
                },
                "chat_identity": {
                  "platform": "chat:workspace-acme",
                  "user_id": "U01LEE"
                },
                "id": "human:lee"
              },
              {
                "authority": {
                  "actions": [
                    "refund"
                  ],
                  "max_amount": 100,
                  "targets": [
                    "billing:acme/"
                  ]
                },
                "chat_identity": {
                  "platform": "chat:workspace-acme",
                  "user_id": "U02ANA"
                },
                "id": "human:ana"
              }
            ],
            "claims": {
              "approval_bound_to_digest": true,
              "approver_verified": true,
              "exact_action_rendered": true,
              "executed_only_approved": true,
              "single_use": true
            },
            "executions": [
              {
                "action_sha256": "b29d15a9b22c00598d24fc45a4456bcb48cf2549df3bf19ef3ae7d087e112716",
                "approval_id": "A1",
                "at": 160.0,
                "request_id": "R1"
              },
              {
                "action_sha256": "9bf54903cf9fb555becb8eba6ea6bde3fe12a1eb8235a065298684b912a32f3e",
                "approval_id": "A2",
                "at": 270.0,
                "request_id": "R2"
              }
            ],
            "requests": [
              {
                "action": {
                  "amount": 240.0,
                  "currency": "USD",
                  "kind": "refund",
                  "target": "billing:acme/order-881"
                },
                "at": 100.0,
                "expires_at": 1000.0,
                "id": "R1",
                "posted_by": "agent:ops-bot",
                "posted_in": {
                  "channel": "chat:#ops-approvals",
                  "message_id": "m-R1"
                },
                "rendered": {
                  "action_sha256": "b29d15a9b22c00598d24fc45a4456bcb48cf2549df3bf19ef3ae7d087e112716",
                  "consequence": "Refund USD 240.00 to the customer's card for order 881; cannot be reversed.",
                  "target": "billing:acme/order-881"
                },
                "requested_by": "human:dana"
              },
              {
                "action": {
                  "amount": 0,
                  "kind": "rotate_key",
                  "target": "kms:acme/payments-signing"
                },
                "at": 200.0,
                "expires_at": 1200.0,
                "id": "R2",
                "posted_by": "agent:ops-bot",
                "posted_in": {
                  "channel": "chat:#ops-approvals",
                  "message_id": "m-R2"
                },
                "rendered": {
                  "action_sha256": "9bf54903cf9fb555becb8eba6ea6bde3fe12a1eb8235a065298684b912a32f3e",
                  "consequence": "Rotate the payments signing key; old signatures stop verifying in 24 hours.",
                  "target": "kms:acme/payments-signing"
                },
                "requested_by": "human:dana"
              },
              {
                "action": {
                  "amount": 80.0,
                  "currency": "USD",
                  "kind": "refund",
                  "target": "billing:acme/order-902"
                },
                "at": 300.0,
                "expires_at": 900.0,
                "id": "R3",
                "posted_by": "agent:ops-bot",
                "posted_in": {
                  "channel": "chat:#ops-approvals",
                  "message_id": "m-R3"
                },
                "rendered": {
                  "action_sha256": "12693820d4961b1bc3af5c3c900658a3c9edee33186e94c15427be7ccb7fa099",
                  "consequence": "Refund USD 80.00 for order 902; cannot be reversed.",
                  "target": "billing:acme/order-902"
                },
                "requested_by": "human:dana"
              }
            ],
            "schema": "cain42.a75.chatapproval.review.v1"
          },
          "subject_sha256": "7d5c66a717a1f79ada4a152b3e5d07c925fec167d8fe25af6e5b48b2c84a1b98",
          "verdict": "SOUND"
        }
      ],
      "run_hash": "1ea37d1bd3aaece1300286c3ac93c45a33745c1946177134e0e1da2d0dccc564",
      "schema": "cain42.a75.chatapproval.run.v1",
      "sku": "CAIN-A75-063",
      "verdict": "VERIFIED",
      "verdicts": [
        "SOUND"
      ]
    },
    "scenarios": [
      {
        "approvals": 2,
        "executions": 2,
        "name": "ops_channel_approvals",
        "requests": 3,
        "run_hash": "1ea37d1bd3aaece1300286c3ac93c45a33745c1946177134e0e1da2d0dccc564",
        "verdict": "VERIFIED"
      },
      {
        "expected": "SOUND",
        "name": "honest_chat_approvals",
        "verdict": "SOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "SOUND",
        "name": "second_approver_inside_limit",
        "verdict": "SOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "amount_changed_after_approval",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "approval_replayed",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "approval_used_for_other_request",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "spoofed_chat_user",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "approval_from_other_workspace",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "free_text_yes_in_thread",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "agent_approved_its_request",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "requester_approved_own_request",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "approver_over_amount_limit",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "approver_lacks_action",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "unregistered_approver",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "approved_after_expiry",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "executed_after_expiry",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "executed_before_approval",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "shown_action_differs",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "shown_target_differs",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "consequence_not_shown",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "nonce_reused",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "executed_without_approval",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "unknown_claim",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "wrong_schema",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "garbage",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      }
    ],
    "summary": "VERIFIED: rendered action digests, structured digest-bound approvals, chat identity and approver authority, single use and execution of exactly the approved action recomputed; 24/24 failure cases as expected"
  },
  "schema": "cain42.agentic75.findings.v1",
  "sku": "CAIN-A75-063"
}
