# Commerce Refusal Review

**SKU:** CAIN-A75-057  
**Development:** #57 Shopping benchmarks that reward refusing bad purchases  
**Product status:** DELIVERABLE  
**Engine:** `commerce_refusal` (`cain_a75_engines/commercerefusal/engine.py`)  
**Profile:** `commerce_refusal`  
**Generated:** 2026-11-13T03:32:40Z UTC

## Result

VERIFIED: every commerce refusal replayed in time order: look-alike merchant, over-limit amount, velocity, budget, currency, agent and revocation each DENY with the right reason, and no refused payment settled; 25/25 failure cases as expected

- **commerce_refusal**: VERIFIED
- **honest_wallet_log**: SOUND
- **larger_budget_redecided**: SOUND
- **lookalike_merchant_paid**: UNSOUND
- **over_per_payment_limit_paid**: UNSOUND
- **velocity_limit_ignored**: UNSOUND
- **budget_exceeded**: UNSOUND
- **wrong_currency_paid**: UNSOUND
- **another_agent_used_the_mandate**: UNSOUND
- **paid_after_revocation**: UNSOUND
- **denied_payment_still_settled**: UNSOUND
- **allowed_payment_never_settled**: UNSOUND
- **wrong_denial_reason**: UNSOUND
- **valid_payment_wrongly_denied**: UNSOUND
- **mandate_edited_after_decisions**: UNSOUND
- **decision_cites_another_mandate**: UNSOUND
- **mandate_from_an_agent**: UNSOUND
- **per_payment_above_total**: UNSOUND
- **spent_understated**: UNSOUND
- **denials_hidden**: UNSOUND
- **negative_amount_paid**: UNSOUND
- **amount_in_floating_dollars**: UNSOUND
- **log_out_of_time_order**: UNSOUND
- **unknown_claim**: UNSOUND
- **wrong_schema**: UNSOUND
- **garbage**: UNSOUND

## Limits of this run

Reviews the commerce decision log. It moves no money, contacts no payment network, and cannot see a refusal that was never logged. The run is Ed25519-signed; pin the issuer key out of band.

This is a bounded run on a sample. It is not an assessment of any production system, not a
certification, and not a signed attestation. The accompanying `manifest.json` records SHA-256
hashes so a recipient can detect a changed file. The manifest is not a signature and not an
attestation; it does not prove who produced the artifact.

## What this is not

- Not a vendor integration, partnership or endorsement.
- Not legal, tax, clinical, insurance or safety advice.
- Not a third-party audit, SOC 2 report, ISO certification or patent filing.
- Not a production write action: no downstream tool was called.

Prices and packaging are proposals. Built by a three-person team.
