{
  "created_at": "2026-11-13T03:32:40Z",
  "result": {
    "engine": "commerce_refusal",
    "limits": "Reviews the commerce decision log. It moves no money, contacts no payment network, and cannot see a refusal that was never logged. The run is Ed25519-signed; pin the issuer key out of band.",
    "module": "cain_a75_engines/commercerefusal/engine.py",
    "profile": "commerce_refusal",
    "run": {
      "label": "Replays an agent's commerce decision log against its mandate and checks every refusal: look-alike merchant, over-limit amount, velocity, budget, currency, agent and revocation must be DENY with the right reason, and no refused payment may settle.",
      "public_key_b64": "2CHOFuo5wcqrHMvIQHTsHuzduhtU7GnEeT4T7Kis1So=",
      "records": [
        {
          "checks": [
            {
              "detail": "principal 'human:office-manager', agent 'agent:procurement'",
              "id": "mandate.principal",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "per payment 20000, total 50000, valid 1000.0..90000.0",
              "id": "mandate.limits",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "stated 19e7f9cb27d807d7, recomputed 19e7f9cb27d807d7",
              "id": "mandate.digest",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "10 requests",
              "id": "transactions.time_ordered",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "recorded 'ALLOW', recomputed 'ALLOW' for 12000 at 'staples.example.com'",
              "id": "tx.P1.decision",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "settled True, recomputed decision 'ALLOW'",
              "id": "tx.P1.settlement",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "recorded 'DENY' ('unknown_merchant'), recomputed 'DENY' ('unknown_merchant') for 9000 at 'staples-example.com.deals.shop'",
              "id": "tx.P2.decision",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "settled False, recomputed decision 'DENY'",
              "id": "tx.P2.settlement",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "recorded 'DENY' ('over_per_transaction_limit'), recomputed 'DENY' ('over_per_transaction_limit') for 25000 at 'paper.example.org'",
              "id": "tx.P3.decision",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "settled False, recomputed decision 'DENY'",
              "id": "tx.P3.settlement",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "recorded 'ALLOW', recomputed 'ALLOW' for 15000 at 'paper.example.org'",
              "id": "tx.P4.decision",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "settled True, recomputed decision 'ALLOW'",
              "id": "tx.P4.settlement",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "recorded 'ALLOW', recomputed 'ALLOW' for 8000 at 'staples.example.com'",
              "id": "tx.P5.decision",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "settled True, recomputed decision 'ALLOW'",
              "id": "tx.P5.settlement",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "recorded 'DENY' ('velocity_exceeded'), recomputed 'DENY' ('velocity_exceeded') for 3000 at 'staples.example.com'",
              "id": "tx.P6.decision",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "settled False, recomputed decision 'DENY'",
              "id": "tx.P6.settlement",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "recorded 'DENY' ('over_budget'), recomputed 'DENY' ('over_budget') for 18000 at 'paper.example.org'",
              "id": "tx.P7.decision",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "settled False, recomputed decision 'DENY'",
              "id": "tx.P7.settlement",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "recorded 'DENY' ('wrong_currency'), recomputed 'DENY' ('wrong_currency') for 4000 at 'paper.example.org'",
              "id": "tx.P8.decision",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "settled False, recomputed decision 'DENY'",
              "id": "tx.P8.settlement",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "recorded 'DENY' ('wrong_agent'), recomputed 'DENY' ('wrong_agent') for 5000 at 'staples.example.com'",
              "id": "tx.P9.decision",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "settled False, recomputed decision 'DENY'",
              "id": "tx.P9.settlement",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "recorded 'DENY' ('revoked'), recomputed 'DENY' ('revoked') for 1000 at 'staples.example.com'",
              "id": "tx.P10.decision",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "settled False, recomputed decision 'DENY'",
              "id": "tx.P10.settlement",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "stated [3, 7, 35000], recomputed [3, 7, 35000]",
              "id": "published.totals",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "claimed True, computed True",
              "id": "claims.every_decision_correct",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "claimed True, computed True",
              "id": "claims.mandate_well_formed",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "claimed True, computed True",
              "id": "claims.only_allowed_payments_settled",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "detail": "claimed True, computed True",
              "id": "claims.totals_match",
              "ok": true
            }
          ],
          "created_at": "2026-11-13T03:32:40Z",
          "engine": "a75-057/1.0.0",
          "extra": {
            "allowed": 3,
            "budget_left": 15000,
            "computed": {
              "every_decision_correct": true,
              "mandate_well_formed": true,
              "only_allowed_payments_settled": true,
              "totals_match": true
            },
            "currency": "USD",
            "denial_reasons": {
              "over_budget": 1,
              "over_per_transaction_limit": 1,
              "revoked": 1,
              "unknown_merchant": 1,
              "velocity_exceeded": 1,
              "wrong_agent": 1,
              "wrong_currency": 1
            },
            "denied": 7,
            "requests": 10,
            "spent": 35000
          },
          "failed": [],
          "label": "Replays an agent's commerce decision log against its mandate and checks every refusal: look-alike merchant, over-limit amount, velocity, budget, currency, agent and revocation must be DENY with the right reason, and no refused payment may settle.",
          "prev_record_hash": "c8b9f901eb4badb301232ab121a97b183c2157df6a96aa7c562641af67295c9a",
          "public_key_b64": "2CHOFuo5wcqrHMvIQHTsHuzduhtU7GnEeT4T7Kis1So=",
          "record_hash": "17beb24f4fdd27bdbc1ea687ccb428a0ca00ec23a32435d97178687089b96d89",
          "schema": "cain42.a75.commercerefusal.record.v1",
          "signature_b64": "60/amQeu+3qnDmAQw4pTkRfM8dcm4Ib8807YwY7XBQ8NlJ5mMAtS+kC6+7ucrUEseWbIDAk+Tsq9Eq26t4CyCg==",
          "sku": "CAIN-A75-057",
          "subject": {
            "claims": {
              "every_decision_correct": true,
              "mandate_well_formed": true,
              "only_allowed_payments_settled": true,
              "totals_match": true
            },
            "mandate": {
              "agent": "agent:procurement",
              "currency": "USD",
              "expires_at": 90000.0,
              "id": "mandate:office-supplies-2026-11",
              "max_per_transaction": 20000,
              "merchants": [
                "staples.example.com",
                "paper.example.org"
              ],
              "not_before": 1000.0,
              "principal": "human:office-manager",
              "revoked_at": 80000.0,
              "total_budget": 50000,
              "velocity": {
                "max_transactions": 3,
                "window_seconds": 3600.0
              }
            },
            "mandate_sha256": "19e7f9cb27d807d7e7c78866a9fc2d230a433339137470943ab7cd50ce651561",
            "published": {
              "allowed": 3,
              "denied": 7,
              "spent": 35000
            },
            "schema": "cain42.a75.walletmandate.review.v1",
            "transactions": [
              {
                "agent": "agent:procurement",
                "amount": 12000,
                "at": 2000.0,
                "currency": "USD",
                "decision": "ALLOW",
                "id": "P1",
                "mandate_sha256": "19e7f9cb27d807d7e7c78866a9fc2d230a433339137470943ab7cd50ce651561",
                "merchant": "staples.example.com",
                "settled": true
              },
              {
                "agent": "agent:procurement",
                "amount": 9000,
                "at": 2100.0,
                "currency": "USD",
                "decision": "DENY",
                "id": "P2",
                "mandate_sha256": "19e7f9cb27d807d7e7c78866a9fc2d230a433339137470943ab7cd50ce651561",
                "merchant": "staples-example.com.deals.shop",
                "reason": "unknown_merchant",
                "settled": false
              },
              {
                "agent": "agent:procurement",
                "amount": 25000,
                "at": 2200.0,
                "currency": "USD",
                "decision": "DENY",
                "id": "P3",
                "mandate_sha256": "19e7f9cb27d807d7e7c78866a9fc2d230a433339137470943ab7cd50ce651561",
                "merchant": "paper.example.org",
                "reason": "over_per_transaction_limit",
                "settled": false
              },
              {
                "agent": "agent:procurement",
                "amount": 15000,
                "at": 2300.0,
                "currency": "USD",
                "decision": "ALLOW",
                "id": "P4",
                "mandate_sha256": "19e7f9cb27d807d7e7c78866a9fc2d230a433339137470943ab7cd50ce651561",
                "merchant": "paper.example.org",
                "settled": true
              },
              {
                "agent": "agent:procurement",
                "amount": 8000,
                "at": 2400.0,
                "currency": "USD",
                "decision": "ALLOW",
                "id": "P5",
                "mandate_sha256": "19e7f9cb27d807d7e7c78866a9fc2d230a433339137470943ab7cd50ce651561",
                "merchant": "staples.example.com",
                "settled": true
              },
              {
                "agent": "agent:procurement",
                "amount": 3000,
                "at": 2500.0,
                "currency": "USD",
                "decision": "DENY",
                "id": "P6",
                "mandate_sha256": "19e7f9cb27d807d7e7c78866a9fc2d230a433339137470943ab7cd50ce651561",
                "merchant": "staples.example.com",
                "reason": "velocity_exceeded",
                "settled": false
              },
              {
                "agent": "agent:procurement",
                "amount": 18000,
                "at": 9000.0,
                "currency": "USD",
                "decision": "DENY",
                "id": "P7",
                "mandate_sha256": "19e7f9cb27d807d7e7c78866a9fc2d230a433339137470943ab7cd50ce651561",
                "merchant": "paper.example.org",
                "reason": "over_budget",
                "settled": false
              },
              {
                "agent": "agent:procurement",
                "amount": 4000,
                "at": 9100.0,
                "currency": "EUR",
                "decision": "DENY",
                "id": "P8",
                "mandate_sha256": "19e7f9cb27d807d7e7c78866a9fc2d230a433339137470943ab7cd50ce651561",
                "merchant": "paper.example.org",
                "reason": "wrong_currency",
                "settled": false
              },
              {
                "agent": "agent:other",
                "amount": 5000,
                "at": 9200.0,
                "currency": "USD",
                "decision": "DENY",
                "id": "P9",
                "mandate_sha256": "19e7f9cb27d807d7e7c78866a9fc2d230a433339137470943ab7cd50ce651561",
                "merchant": "staples.example.com",
                "reason": "wrong_agent",
                "settled": false
              },
              {
                "agent": "agent:procurement",
                "amount": 1000,
                "at": 85000.0,
                "currency": "USD",
                "decision": "DENY",
                "id": "P10",
                "mandate_sha256": "19e7f9cb27d807d7e7c78866a9fc2d230a433339137470943ab7cd50ce651561",
                "merchant": "staples.example.com",
                "reason": "revoked",
                "settled": false
              }
            ]
          },
          "subject_sha256": "9e2c94d99d1f68c87a23ccd58f082083a63488704a2fe5d9689c45583ea6a7af",
          "verdict": "SOUND"
        }
      ],
      "run_hash": "831fae94f58ac4d567299310826ba53d2103ce73f4c63d5abff30c5fad75eee2",
      "schema": "cain42.a75.commercerefusal.run.v1",
      "sku": "CAIN-A75-057",
      "verdict": "VERIFIED",
      "verdicts": [
        "SOUND"
      ]
    },
    "scenarios": [
      {
        "allowed": 3,
        "denial_reasons": {
          "over_budget": 1,
          "over_per_transaction_limit": 1,
          "revoked": 1,
          "unknown_merchant": 1,
          "velocity_exceeded": 1,
          "wrong_agent": 1,
          "wrong_currency": 1
        },
        "denied": 7,
        "name": "commerce_refusal",
        "requests": 10,
        "run_hash": "831fae94f58ac4d567299310826ba53d2103ce73f4c63d5abff30c5fad75eee2",
        "spent": 35000,
        "verdict": "VERIFIED"
      },
      {
        "expected": "SOUND",
        "name": "honest_wallet_log",
        "verdict": "SOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "SOUND",
        "name": "larger_budget_redecided",
        "verdict": "SOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "lookalike_merchant_paid",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "over_per_payment_limit_paid",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "velocity_limit_ignored",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "budget_exceeded",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "wrong_currency_paid",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "another_agent_used_the_mandate",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "paid_after_revocation",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "denied_payment_still_settled",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "allowed_payment_never_settled",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "wrong_denial_reason",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "valid_payment_wrongly_denied",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "mandate_edited_after_decisions",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "decision_cites_another_mandate",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "mandate_from_an_agent",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "per_payment_above_total",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "spent_understated",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "denials_hidden",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "negative_amount_paid",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "amount_in_floating_dollars",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "log_out_of_time_order",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "unknown_claim",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "wrong_schema",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      },
      {
        "expected": "UNSOUND",
        "name": "garbage",
        "verdict": "UNSOUND"
      }
    ],
    "summary": "VERIFIED: every commerce refusal replayed in time order: look-alike merchant, over-limit amount, velocity, budget, currency, agent and revocation each DENY with the right reason, and no refused payment settled; 25/25 failure cases as expected"
  },
  "schema": "cain42.agentic75.findings.v1",
  "sku": "CAIN-A75-057"
}
