# CAIN-A75-055 Memory Evaluation Review

**Verdict:** VERIFIED

> Recomputes a multi-session memory evaluation on four axes: recall, scope, freshness and authority effect. A memory recalled into the wrong tenant or purpose is a failure, not a hit. It does not run the agent.

| Agent | Verdict | Recall | Scope | Freshness | Authority | Failed checks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 agent:support-bot | SOUND | 2/3 | 5/5 | 5/5 | 5/5 |  |

## What this proves and what it does not
- Proves: every memory names its tenant, purpose, validity window, an existing source version, a content hash and its writer, and none claims to grant authority; every probe is re-scored here on recall, scope (no memory from another tenant or purpose), freshness (nothing expired, deleted or superseded at the task time) and authority (no action took its authority from a memory); recall, refusal and supersession are all probed with well-formed expectations; and the stated per-probe results, totals and claims equal the recomputation.
- Does not prove: that the probes are hard enough, that the retrieved lists are what the agent really retrieved, or anything about memory content. It is an evaluation-record review; a SOUND verdict can still carry real gaps.
- Verify offline: `python3 verify_offline.py run.json --pinned-key cN63m42Oig39aYV0nJAXrAuVoTjIynT1T3y7J2di2HI=`
