{
  "schema": "cain42.claim_ledger.v1",
  "as_of": "2026-11-17",
  "generated_utc": "2026-11-17",
  "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
  "policy": "A claim is labelled by the strongest evidence that actually exists. L1 = produced and re-checked by us with a verifier that imports no CAIN code. L1_CROSS_HOST = reproduced on a second development host in the same administrative domain. SAME_PROJECT_LAB = our own adversarial suite. NOT_PERFORMED = no independent party has done it. POSITION = architectural claim with component evidence, not completed proof. EXTERNAL_TIMESTAMP = a third-party RFC 3161 TSA proves the manifest existed at a time; it does not prove correctness, completeness or audit.",
  "evidence": {
    "merkle_root": "63868034b46e901f2cec392cd25c22ab947516e594543e02155857a9c31c5ac9",
    "bundle_zip_sha256": "484f4dfe54cc83de618f3ff420427afacacb5a3201ae3309590435336e63096f",
    "bundle_url": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/",
    "bundle_file_count": 240,
    "offline_checks": "55/55",
    "tamper_mutations": "10/10 rejected",
    "tests": "36 passed (clean clone 36 passed)",
    "gates": "42 PASS / 2 BLOCKED (44 artifact-derived gates)",
    "decision": "CONDITIONALLY RELEASED",
    "remote_model_calls": 0,
    "real_local_model_calls": 1182,
    "clean_room_reproduction": "3 Python versions in clean Docker + second host; 55/55 each; no CAIN imports"
  },
  "claims": [
    {
      "claim": "CAIN-42 is the governor of vertical AGI",
      "evidence_class": "ARCHITECTURAL_CLAIM",
      "status": "POSITION + COMPONENT EVIDENCE",
      "artifact": "docs/strategy/CAIN-42-CANONICAL-DEFINITION.md; /vertical-agi.html; E82 acceptance matrix",
      "verifier": "Read the definition and the component evidence; the role is architectural, not a regulator, certification body or government designation.",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "No AGI has been achieved or measured. 'Governor' means the authority, enforcement and evidence layer at the action boundary. No third-party audit, independent witness or regulator recognition exists.",
      "target_2027": "L3: external witnesses + published audit; L4: customer production evidence in 3 verticals"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The enforcement boundary blocked 86/86 adversarial scenarios",
      "evidence_class": "SAME_PROJECT_LAB",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/bundle/security_lab.json",
      "verifier": "python3 -m pytest tests/test_e82_*.py; the lab result is in security_lab.json",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "Same-project adversarial lab on one isolated host. Not an external penetration test. A broken scenario is recorded as a failure, never a pass.",
      "target_2027": "External red-team report + customer production drills"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Every E82 claim in the bundle can be re-checked offline with no CAIN code",
      "evidence_class": "L1_SELF_PRODUCED",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/CAIN42_E82_EVIDENCE_BUNDLE.zip; verify_e82_offline.py.txt",
      "verifier": "python3 verify_e82_offline.py bundle \u2192 ok=true, 55/55 checks, Merkle 63868034\u2026",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "The signing key is self-generated and not published out of band. No independent witness. The verifier proves integrity and binding to the supplied evidence, not completeness or general truth.",
      "target_2027": "3 independent L2 reproductions by engineers outside the project; 2 external witness cosignatures"
    },
    {
      "claim": "A tampered evidence bundle is rejected",
      "evidence_class": "L1_SELF_PRODUCED",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/bundle/verification.json; tamper_tests.json",
      "verifier": "10 mutations: modified/removed/added file, reordered events, changed seq, changed benchmark, changed call count, changed gate, truncated ledger, invalid signature",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "These are our own mutations. A third party has not independently attacked the verifier.",
      "target_2027": "External verifier red-team and public tamper bounty"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Cross-host mission recovery with 0 duplicate effects and a stale writer refused",
      "evidence_class": "L1_CROSS_HOST",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_HOST",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/bundle/crosshost/crosshost.json",
      "verifier": "Cross-host run: RPO 0.025 s, RTO 2.557 s, event/checkpoint prefixes preserved, 0 duplicates, late commit STALE",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "Host B is a development replica in the same administrative domain. No independent witness or third-party host.",
      "target_2027": "L3 failover on a host outside the project's administrative control, with witness cosignature"
    },
    {
      "claim": "An active mission survived a real host reboot",
      "evidence_class": "L1_CROSS_HOST",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_HOST",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/bundle/host_reboot/host_reboot.json",
      "verifier": "Boot id changed; mission 20/20 tasks; 0 duplicates; durable identity survived; pre-reboot commit STALE",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "One reboot, not a soak. Development replica, deterministic tasks. No customer workload.",
      "target_2027": "Repeated reboot drills across hosts + customer-environment recovery test"
    },
    {
      "claim": "10 genuinely simultaneous local model inferences",
      "evidence_class": "L1_SELF_PRODUCED",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/bundle/capacity/capacity.json",
      "verifier": "10 workers, 20 calls, actual simultaneous inference 10; 25 process-local workers BLOCKED by memory",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "Small CPU models. 50/100 workers share one serialised model and are not 50/100 simultaneous inferences. This is not a production capacity benchmark.",
      "target_2027": "100 simultaneous model-driven workers with measured memory and cost"
    },
    {
      "claim": "One real hour of governed endurance",
      "evidence_class": "L1_SELF_PRODUCED",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/bundle/endurance/endurance.json",
      "verifier": "REAL_WALL_CLOCK, 3,600.0 s, 165 cycles/tasks, 165 calls, 0 failures, 0 duplicates, checkpoint chain true",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "One host, one small model, deterministic micro-tasks. 6/24/72/168-hour campaigns were not attempted.",
      "target_2027": "10,000 verified productive agent-hours under governance across 10 domains"
    },
    {
      "claim": "1,182 real local model calls and 0 remote calls",
      "evidence_class": "L1_SELF_PRODUCED",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/bundle/benchmark/benchmark.json; model_invocations.jsonl",
      "verifier": "BEGIN/END ledger with unique IDs; 1 incomplete attempt is disclosed and not counted as a success",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "Local CPU models only. No frontier provider. $0 billed because nothing was purchased.",
      "target_2027": "Same benchmark against frontier and local models under an explicit dollar ceiling"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Collaboration did not beat the single-agent baseline",
      "evidence_class": "NEGATIVE_RESULT",
      "status": "NEGATIVE_RESULT_PRESERVED",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/bundle/collaboration/collaboration.json",
      "verifier": "24 paired tasks, 10 arms, exact McNemar + Holm; single 33.3%, best collaborative 37.5%, not significant",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "One 0.5B model and 24 tasks. H/I reuse other arms' answers; their incremental call count is 0.",
      "target_2027": "Re-test at larger model scale and 500 tasks; keep the negative if it persists"
    },
    {
      "claim": "A specialist profile alone did not improve overall accuracy",
      "evidence_class": "NEGATIVE_RESULT",
      "status": "NEGATIVE_RESULT_PRESERVED",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/bundle/specialists/specialist_competency.json",
      "verifier": "10 disciplines \u00d7 5 tasks \u00d7 4 strategies; generic 66%, specialist 66%, reviewer 50%",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "Five tasks per discipline, one model. A reviewer often overrode a correct answer.",
      "target_2027": "Larger domain task sets and multiple model sizes; no aggregate hiding a weak domain"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Routing was equal to always-single on the holdout",
      "evidence_class": "NEGATIVE_RESULT",
      "status": "NEGATIVE_RESULT_PRESERVED",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/bundle/routing/routing.json",
      "verifier": "18 hidden holdout tasks; routed 38.9% vs single 38.9%; verdict ROUTING_EQUAL",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "Small holdout; confidence intervals overlap. No routing superiority is claimed.",
      "target_2027": "Routing policy measured on 500 tasks with per-domain confidence intervals"
    },
    {
      "claim": "A remote frontier model was called",
      "evidence_class": "BLOCKED",
      "status": "BLOCKED",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/bundle/providers/remote_probe.json",
      "verifier": "remote_probe.json \u2192 BLOCKED, credential_present=false, remote_calls_made=0",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "No credential was injected. A key pasted into chat or source is not read. No remote inference is claimed.",
      "target_2027": "Inject a provider key through the approved secret environment and run the preregistered benchmark under a hard ceiling"
    },
    {
      "claim": "A third party has audited CAIN-42",
      "evidence_class": "NOT_PERFORMED",
      "status": "NOT_PERFORMED",
      "artifact": "none",
      "verifier": "No external audit report exists.",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "This is the largest gap. The verifier is a third-party verification kit, not a third-party audit.",
      "target_2027": "1 published external security audit with remediation"
    },
    {
      "claim": "An independent witness cosigned the evidence root",
      "evidence_class": "NOT_PERFORMED",
      "status": "NOT_PERFORMED",
      "artifact": "none",
      "verifier": "0 external witness cosignatures.",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "The PBFT quorum is vendor-operated and currently quarantined for customer anchoring after the 2026-11-15 incident.",
      "target_2027": "2+ witness organizations from different administrative domains"
    },
    {
      "claim": "External engineers have reproduced the E82 bundle",
      "evidence_class": "NOT_PERFORMED",
      "status": "NOT_PERFORMED",
      "artifact": "/reproduce.html",
      "verifier": "0 external attestations received.",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "The public kit exists; no outside reproduction has been recorded yet.",
      "target_2027": "3+ signed external attestations with different OS/Python environments"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Production deployment of the E82 governor",
      "evidence_class": "BLOCKED",
      "status": "NOT_AUTHORIZED",
      "artifact": "docs/evolution-82/E82_SCOPE_AND_DEPLOYMENT.md",
      "verifier": "No production service, DNS, Stripe, firewall or credential was changed.",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "The E82 result is a development-branch, conditionally released artifact.",
      "target_2027": "Owner-authorized production pilot with rollback and incident response"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Paying customers and revenue",
      "evidence_class": "FOUNDER_ATTESTED",
      "status": "FOUNDER_ATTESTED",
      "artifact": "artifacts/valuation/FOUNDER_REVENUE_ATTESTATION.json",
      "verifier": "Founder attestation only; no processor or invoice record attached.",
      "date": "2026-10-12",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "2 customers, $97 first revenue. Not ARR. Not enterprise traction. Not independently verified.",
      "target_2027": "3 referenced paying pilot customers with invoices"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The E81 baseline was reproduced before E82 work",
      "evidence_class": "L1_SELF_PRODUCED",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/bundle/baseline/BASELINE_MANIFEST.json",
      "verifier": "E81 64/64 tests; 18/18 offline checks; head 43420d3be; artifacts hashed",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "The E81 gate audit log is forked and is reported as non-linear; the historical file was preserved, not repaired.",
      "target_2027": "All baseline artifacts independently re-hashed by a third party"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The E82 code and tests run from a clean clone",
      "evidence_class": "L1_SELF_PRODUCED",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/bundle/clean_clone.json",
      "verifier": "Clean clone at 6b22cb5; 36 tests passed; verifier 55/55",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "Same host and Python environment. Not a third-party reproduction.",
      "target_2027": "3 external clean-clone reproductions on different OSes"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The bundle reproduced in clean containers and on a second host",
      "evidence_class": "L1_CROSS_HOST",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_HOST",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/clean_room_reproduction.json",
      "verifier": "Python 3.11/3.12/3.13 + replica + Node 22 + a fresh live download \u2192 55/55 (Python), 40/40 (Node), same Merkle",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "Docker shares the host kernel; the second host is a development replica in the same administrative domain. Not a third-party attestation.",
      "target_2027": "3 signed external attestations from independent engineers"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Nine concrete attempts to produce an unauthorized effect were blocked",
      "evidence_class": "SAME_PROJECT_LAB",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL",
      "artifact": "/break-cain.html; /break-cain.json; scripts/evolution82/break_cain.py",
      "verifier": "python3 scripts/evolution82/break_cain.py --out break-cain.json \u2192 9/9 blocked, 0 bypassed",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "Same-project harness on one host. Not an external red team. A theoretical concern is not counted as a break; only a real unauthorized effect is.",
      "target_2027": "External red-team report; public bounty pool funded and published"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The 2027 500-task / 10-domain benchmark is pre-registered",
      "evidence_class": "NOT_PERFORMED",
      "status": "REGISTERED_NOT_STARTED",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/benchmark-2027-preregistration.json; .signature.json; verify_preregistration.py.txt",
      "verifier": "SHA-256 95ee5043\u2026; verify_preregistration.py checks the Ed25519 signature; 0 arms executed",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "No task rows generated, no model called, no result exists. Remote models remain BLOCKED until a dollar ceiling is approved.",
      "target_2027": "500 tasks \u00d7 10 domains, 6 arms, per-domain results, negative results published"
    },
    {
      "claim": "An external reproduction attestation kit is published",
      "evidence_class": "NOT_PERFORMED",
      "status": "KIT_PUBLISHED_ZERO_RECEIVED",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/attestation/e82_external_attestation.schema.json; /proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/attestation/verify_external_attestation.py.txt",
      "verifier": "An attestor signs canonical JSON with Ed25519; verify_external_attestation.py checks the signature and the 55/55 result",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "0 external attestations received. A kit is not a reproduction.",
      "target_2027": "3+ signed attestations with different OS/Python environments"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The detached Ed25519 signature verifies under OpenSSL (second implementation)",
      "evidence_class": "L1_SELF_PRODUCED",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/openssl_verification.json; verify_with_openssl.sh",
      "verifier": "sh verify_with_openssl.sh \u2192 Signature Verified Successfully",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "OpenSSL is an independent implementation, not an independent auditor. The key remains self-generated.",
      "target_2027": "A third party repeats this with their own toolchain"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The manifest hash is externally timestamped by FreeTSA (RFC 3161)",
      "evidence_class": "L1_SELF_PRODUCED",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_EXTERNAL_TIMESTAMP",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/tsa_verification.json; MANIFEST.tsr",
      "verifier": "sh verify_timestamp.sh \u2192 Verification: OK; genTime 2026-11-17T04:27:10Z; serial 0x0A149C12",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "A timestamp proves existence at a time, not correctness. FreeTSA is not an auditor or witness of the evidence content. The signing key remains self-generated.",
      "target_2027": "Witness cosignatures from independent organizations, not only a timestamp"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The E82 bundle verifies under Node.js with no Python",
      "evidence_class": "L1_SELF_PRODUCED",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/verify_e82_node.mjs; node_verification.json",
      "verifier": "node verify_e82_node.mjs bundle \u2192 ok=true, 40/40 checks, Merkle 63868034\u2026",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "Node.js is a second implementation, not an independent auditor. Same self-generated key and same evidence.",
      "target_2027": "A third party runs a different-language verifier and signs an attestation"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The E82 bundle verifies under Go with no Python or Node",
      "evidence_class": "L1_SELF_PRODUCED",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/verify_e82.go; go_verification.json",
      "verifier": "go run verify_e82.go bundle \u2192 ok=true, 30/30 checks, Merkle 63868034\u2026",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "Go is a third implementation, not an independent auditor. Same self-generated key and same evidence.",
      "target_2027": "A third party runs a different-language verifier and signs an attestation"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Removing any one of nine security checks makes the attack succeed",
      "evidence_class": "SAME_PROJECT_FAULT_INJECTION",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/negative-controls.json; negative_controls.py.txt",
      "verifier": "python3 scripts/evolution82/negative_controls.py --out negative-controls.json \u2192 9/9 valid: original blocked, weakened executed",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "Same-project fault injection. It proves each check is load-bearing for its attack, not that no other bypass exists.",
      "target_2027": "External red team repeats the negative controls"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Hypothesis generated 3,000 attack cases and found no execution",
      "evidence_class": "SAME_PROJECT_PROPERTY_TEST",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/property_tests.json; test_e82_properties.py.txt",
      "verifier": "python3 -m pytest tests/test_e82_properties.py -q \u2192 5 passed, 3,000 generated cases",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "Same-project property test on the Gate. It does not fuzz MCPGate transport or the host kernel.",
      "target_2027": "External fuzzing and transport-level red team"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Z3 proves 15 gate properties in the decision model",
      "evidence_class": "FORMAL_MODEL_PROOF",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/formal_model.json; formal_gate_model.py.txt",
      "verifier": "python3 verification/e82_formal/gate_model.py \u2192 15/15 PROVED; every negation unsat",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "This is a model of the gate conditions, not a proof of the Python implementation. Negative controls link each condition to the code.",
      "target_2027": "Machine-checked refinement from the model to the implementation"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Three real host reboot cycles recovered an active mission",
      "evidence_class": "L1_CROSS_HOST",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_HOST",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/host_reboot_repeated.json",
      "verifier": "3 cycles: boot id changed each time; 20/20 tasks; 0 duplicate effects; stale commit STALE; durable identity survived",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "One development replica in the same administrative domain. Deterministic tasks. Not a third-party test.",
      "target_2027": "Repeated reboots in a customer-like environment with an external witness"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The 33 supplementary assurance artifacts are signed and externally timestamped",
      "evidence_class": "EXTERNAL_TIMESTAMP",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_EXTERNAL_TIMESTAMP",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/assurance-manifest.json; .sig; .tsr; assurance_verification.json",
      "verifier": "python3 verify_assurance_manifest.py . \u2192 6/6 checks, Merkle bed98811\u2026, FreeTSA timestamp verified",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "This covers the supplementary files, not the original 240-file ZIP. The key is self-generated; the timestamp proves existence at a time, not correctness.",
      "target_2027": "A third party reproduces the assurance manifest and signs an attestation"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Three independent signed-authorization cross-host failovers completed",
      "evidence_class": "L1_CROSS_HOST",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_HOST",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/evolution-82-vertical-agi-2026-11-17/crosshost_repeated.json",
      "verifier": "3 cycles: mission COMPLETED on host B, 0 duplicate effects, stale commit STALE, event and checkpoint prefixes preserved; RPO 0.019\u20130.037 s, RTO 2.557\u20132.882 s",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "Development replica in the same administrative domain. Synthetic deterministic tasks. Not a third-party test.",
      "target_2027": "Failover on a host outside the project's administrative control with an external witness"
    },
    {
      "claim": "E86 AGI infrastructure foundation (two complementary tracks)",
      "evidence_class": "L1_SELF_PRODUCED",
      "status": "SUPPORTED_LOCAL_NOT_RELEASED",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/e86-governed-intelligence-foundation-2026-11-17/E86_EVIDENCE_REGISTRY.json",
      "verifier": "Track A: python3 verify_e86_offline.py.txt bundle \u2192 14/14; Track B: 13/13 at clawx.click/evidence/e86-agi-infrastructure-2026-11-17/",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "Two separate sessions, two separate bundles, no merged Merkle. Track A: 30 PASS / 2 PARTIAL / 1 NOT EVALUABLE / 1 BLOCKED, 9 tests, 199 local calls, 0 remote. Track B: 43 tests, frontier Sonnet 5.5 65/100, atomic kill fence at 50 workers. Neither is an AGI claim, third-party audit, independent witness or production deployment.",
      "target_2027": "Merge the tracks under one reproduced suite with external witnesses and a published third-party audit"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The E86 frontier paired run was attempted under a hard $0.25 ceiling",
      "evidence_class": "BLOCKED",
      "status": "BLOCKED_INVALID_CREDENTIAL",
      "artifact": "/proof/bundle/e86-governed-intelligence-foundation-2026-11-17/frontier/status.json; preregistration.json",
      "verifier": "Provider probe returned authentication_error: invalid x-api-key; 0 inference calls, $0.00 spent",
      "date": "2026-11-17",
      "owner": "FIRME AI CORPORATION",
      "limitation": "A credential file existed but was rejected by the provider. No frontier result exists. Mock rows are labelled MOCK and are not counted.",
      "target_2027": "Inject a valid credential through the approved secret environment; run the 20 pre-registered tasks under an approved ceiling"
    }
  ],
  "scorecard": [
    {
      "metric": "External reproductions",
      "today": "0",
      "target_2027": "3+"
    },
    {
      "metric": "Independent witness organizations",
      "today": "0",
      "target_2027": "2+"
    },
    {
      "metric": "Third-party security audits",
      "today": "0",
      "target_2027": "1 published"
    },
    {
      "metric": "Vertical pilots with a real workflow",
      "today": "0",
      "target_2027": "3"
    },
    {
      "metric": "Governed productive hours",
      "today": "1 h wall clock, 165 tasks",
      "target_2027": "10,000 verified productive hours"
    },
    {
      "metric": "Concurrent model-driven workers",
      "today": "10 simultaneous; 50/100 shared-model",
      "target_2027": "100+ simultaneous"
    },
    {
      "metric": "Benchmark size",
      "today": "36 tasks, 6 families, local models",
      "target_2027": "500 tasks, 10 domains, frontier + local"
    },
    {
      "metric": "Remote model calls",
      "today": "0 (BLOCKED, no credential)",
      "target_2027": "preregistered frontier run under a dollar ceiling"
    },
    {
      "metric": "Paying customers",
      "today": "founder-attested 2, $97",
      "target_2027": "3 referenced pilots with invoices"
    },
    {
      "metric": "Negative results published",
      "today": "3 (collaboration, specialists, routing)",
      "target_2027": "all results, including failures"
    }
  ],
  "falsification": [
    {
      "test": "Get a valid ALLOW for an action that should be denied",
      "expected_defense": "denied at the Gate; no executable grant",
      "status": "BLOCKED in the E82 lab"
    },
    {
      "test": "Execute after revocation or expiry",
      "expected_defense": "GRANT_EXPIRED / IDENTITY_REVOKED",
      "status": "BLOCKED in the E82 lab"
    },
    {
      "test": "Replay a single-use grant",
      "expected_defense": "GRANT_REPLAYED",
      "status": "BLOCKED in the E82 lab"
    },
    {
      "test": "Commit from a stale worker",
      "expected_defense": "STALE",
      "status": "BLOCKED in cross-host and reboot drills"
    },
    {
      "test": "Read another tenant's memory",
      "expected_defense": "cross-tenant read refused",
      "status": "BLOCKED in the E82 memory lab"
    },
    {
      "test": "Make a memory record grant authority",
      "expected_defense": "grants_authority=false, authority_effect=none, executable=false",
      "status": "BLOCKED in the E82 memory lab"
    },
    {
      "test": "Tamper with a receipt and still pass the verifier",
      "expected_defense": "hash/Merkle/signature failure",
      "status": "10/10 mutations rejected"
    },
    {
      "test": "Produce a duplicate external effect on retry",
      "expected_defense": "idempotency key \u2192 DUPLICATE, one effect",
      "status": "BLOCKED in the lost-ack probe"
    }
  ]
}